2023 state of SMS marketing: Poor mobile messaging strategy drives brand decline

by | Mar 7, 2023 | Marketing, Public Relations

New survey research from data quality and email marketing firm Validity of SMS, text, and WhatsApp users determines that when done well, SMS marketing encourages customer engagement and spending—but when done poorly, it can have crippling implications for a company’s bottom line.

SMS marketing has become a widely adopted practice, with 91 percent of consumers interested in signing up for texts. Additionally, when complemented with email marketing efforts, has enabled brands to reach an array of customers directly on their personal mobile device, as well as increase user lifetime by 76 percent. With timely promotional pings and reminders of an abandoned cart, SMS and messaging drives customers to buy.

The firm’s new State of SMS Marketing in 2023 report in fact found that 38 percent of customers have been influenced to purchase a service and 50 percent have been influenced to purchase a product because of a brand message they received via text or WhatsApp. Moreover, customers prefer it when their favorite brands use more than one marketing channel to engage them, highlighting the potential of SMS and email marketing campaigns. Through SMS marketing, you can send personalized, target messages on your terms.

However, there is a fine line between positive and negative brand experiences when it comes to SMS

A major concern is a perceived lack of purchase history knowledge and blatant disregard for customer communication preferences. Why does this matter? As customers are bombarded with more mobile communication than ever before, marketers risk losing customers and valuable revenue if they don’t create personalized messages that are delivered at the desired cadence. Notably, 96 percent of respondents report finding themselves at least occasionally annoyed with SMS marketing, particularly when messages aren’t relevant to their needs or contain products that they’ve already purchased.

2023 state of SMS marketing: Poor mobile messaging strategy drives brand decline

Some customers go as far as abandoning a brand due to this irritation. In fact, 28 percent of those who have felt annoyed from brand messages have completely stopped doing business with companies and 28 percent report purchasing less—entirely due to irritation with a brand’s marketing text messages.

What’s worse, poor SMS practices extend beyond a single disgruntled customer

Fourteen percent of customers surveyed that have felt annoyed from brand messages report having left a negative public review of a company due to irritation with marketing text messages. When implementing ill-crafted SMS strategies, marketers create a domino effect of poor experiences, lost customers, decreased revenue, and damaged brand reputation—all of which can be mitigated by honoring customer preference.

“With bleak economic conditions projected for the coming months, it is increasingly critical to reach customers where they’re at—which in today’s world is via SMS,” said Kate Adams, SVP of marketing at Validity, in a news release. “Marketers who’ve mastered the art of SMS are able to create campaigns that increase customer engagement and satisfaction, and ultimately drive revenue for their business. But the findings of this report are also a cautionary tale because the opposite is equally true. When SMS is done poorly, businesses risk alienating large swaths of customers.”

2023 state of SMS marketing: Poor mobile messaging strategy drives brand decline

“Unfortunately, many marketers don’t know how to incorporate SMS effectively, and often attempt to apply age-old email marketing tactics—which aren’t effective in this medium,” said Adams. “It’s crucial that businesses invest in training for their marketing teams so they are able to effectively adjust how, where, and with what frequency to employ SMS messaging tactics.”

Additional key report findings include:

  • 19 percent of respondents list SMS as their most preferred brand communication channel (ranked above email, social media, direct mail, or app notifications). In fact, 16 percent would ideally like to receive these messages from brands 2-3 times per week.
  • Nearly half (49 percent) of respondents reported that brands messaging too frequently was what annoyed them most about SMS messaging.
  • To mitigate this challenge, brands should consider giving consumers the ability to customize the frequency with which they receive messages from brands. In fact, 97 percent of respondents report that they would prefer this feature and, of those, 81 percent say that this capability would make them more likely to purchase from or do business with a brand.
  • Data privacy also poses a risk for customers with 70 percent reporting they’re worried that texts from brands might pose a data risk. Of those, 66 percent are concerned about companies selling their data and/or clicking links within brand messages due to risk of scammers.
  • But the majority of customers are willing to risk it, with 66 percent of respondents who believe SMS messages from brands pose a data risk, reporting they continue to sign up for texts, SMS, and messages from brands because of the potential rewards—including company updates, shipping notifications, and free merchandise.

2023 state of SMS marketing: Poor mobile messaging strategy drives brand decline

Download the full report here.

Validity conducted the State of SMS Marketing survey online between November 25 and December 4, 2022. It reflects the opinions of 1,218 consumers with access to mobile devices that can receive texts, SMS, or WhatsApp messages in the United States, United Kingdom, Australia, or New Zealand, and was conducted at 95 percent confidence with a +/- 3 percent margin of error.

Richard Carufel
Richard Carufel is editor of Bulldog Reporter and the Daily ’Dog, one of the web’s leading sources of PR and marketing communications news and opinions. He has been reporting on the PR and communications industry for over 17 years, and has interviewed hundreds of journalists and PR industry leaders. Reach him at richard.carufel@bulldogreporter.com; @BulldogReporter


5 strategic ways AI is changing the PR game

5 strategic ways AI is changing the PR game

AI has now become our wise friend next door, who has an answer to all our questions. Every one of us has given it a go, be it to find just the right caption for that Instagram post or to research a new topic thoroughly. No wonder, AI is estimated to potentially...

4 ways to leverage user research for sustainable marketing success

4 ways to leverage user research for sustainable marketing success

Ancient Romans preferred a loss that occurred due to following rules to a victory where one bent or broke the rules. Why? Because in the long run, having/knowing the rules will give you the most consistency and provide the best net-positive results. How did this serve...