Majority of influencers/creators say they’re driven by desire to build community, not money

by | Aug 1, 2022 | Public Relations

Prevailing opinion in the comms industry seems to be that most influencers/creators are in the marketing game for fame and fortune, but new research from MMI Agency finds that 77 percent of influencers in its new survey say they do so because they have a passion for their respective subject areas, and two-thirds (66 percent) want to build a community around shared interests. What’s more, nearly all of those polled (98 percent) say it’s important to work with brands that align with their values.

“While these findings may be surprising to some, the attitudes expressed align perfectly with what we find within our own influencer programs,” said Maggie Malek, CEO of MMI, in a news release. “Out of passion, influencers want to be intimately involved with the brands they represent. They care deeply about the products and services they promote, and they’re willing to work hard to make sure any content they produce is relevant and compelling to their audiences.”

The survey results, conducted by The Harris Poll, also find that the majority (59 percent) prefer the term “creators” to “influencers” expressing that the former term better encapsulates their role in the marketing process. According to one survey subject, “Influencer has some negative connotations and feels a little like you’re bragging. I feel that I create content more than I influence people.”

But there remains a large segment of respondents who stand by “influencer”

“It helps viewers understand that I am here to give suggestions and help people,” says one.

The study polled 140 U.S. adults who are compensated in some form to post original content on social networks for a brand, platform or audience/community, and consider themselves an influencer or creator, with at least 5,000 followers or connections on a social network.

“The role of influencer marketing has grown to be a vital component of the marketer’s playbook,” said Malek. “We commissioned this research to gain new insights into how this tactic can be most effective, in order to provide unquestionable value to the brands we serve and their audiences.”

“Content creators and influencers can’t be bought by brands with misaligned values,” said John Gerzema, CEO of The Harris Poll, in the release. “Influencers are truly obsessed with the category they’re in, they are always in discovery mode and love to bring something fresh and unexpected to their followers. Six in ten (60 percent) say engagement with their followers and building a community is the most significant factor in their overall success. Marketers need to understand this passion. It’s what drives them.”

Other notable findings:

Audience and content are paramount

Three-fifths (61 percent) of creators say brands should keep in mind their audience when partnering with them, and 57 percent say they should keep in mind the need for content to be authentic. Per one respondent: “The most important thing for influencers and creators is the relationship with their audience, so sponsorships or brand endorsements that threaten those relationships are potentially very damaging.”

Money is secondary

Only 12 percent of respondents say revenue is the most significant factor in determining their success.

More ‘influencers’ choose TikTok than ‘creators’

By a significant margin, 72 percent of those who consider themselves influencers are more likely to be on TikTok, versus 54 percent of creators.

One-offs are as common as ambassadorships

Four in 10 (43 percent) say their average brand partnership is just a one-off campaign, while the same number (43 percent) say their brand partnerships are year-long or longer ambassador programs. Only 14 percent say they have permanent or indefinite partnerships with brands. However, more than two-thirds (68 percent) say brands will routinely engage with them again if the original one-off campaign proved successful. Brand partnerships provide a significant chunk of income for many: For nearly a third of creators (31 percent), brand partnerships make up 50 percent or more of their revenue.

Out-of-pocket costs are taking a toll

Nearly two-thirds of creators (63 percent) say out-of-pocket costs such as photoshoots are a significant burden. And close to half (47 percent) say brands should keep these costs in mind when partnering with them.

Half stumbled into the gig, and half sought it out:

About half (52 percent) of respondents say they purposely sought to become an influencer or creator with the aspiration to become popular; 48 percent say they accidentally became an influencer or creator, and are now taking advantage of the following they have.

“These findings can serve as a guide for brands and agencies as they interact with creators moving forward,” said Malek. “The core drivers of creators, revealed in this survey, confirms what we have found in our work: They are authentic and passionate. That’s why they are so effective and why we are so excited to be in this business.”

Richard Carufel
Richard Carufel is editor of Bulldog Reporter and the Daily ’Dog, one of the web’s leading sources of PR and marketing communications news and opinions. He has been reporting on the PR and communications industry for over 17 years, and has interviewed hundreds of journalists and PR industry leaders. Reach him at richard.carufel@bulldogreporter.com; @BulldogReporter