Influencers have gained massive power online over the last few years and, as PR pros know, have even become a new industry standard of successful marketing—but as we know all too well, where there’s power, there can be unscrupulous exploitation. And if there’s truth behind a new line of allegations, this dark side of influencer marketing can be dangerous terrain indeed.
According to new allegations by anti-smoking advocacy group the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, Big Tobacco companies are secretly advertising cigarettes on social media platforms like Instagram, Facebook and Twitter by paying social media influencers—in this case, popular young people with large online followings—to post images of cigarettes and smoking as part of a marketing strategy documented in more than 40 countries.
Following a two-year investigation by the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids and consumer research and consulting firm Netnografica LLC, the findings were published online and detailed in a petition sent to the U.S. Federal Trade Commission by nine leading public health and medical groups.
The investigation documents more than 100 alleged social media campaigns by multinational tobacco giants Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Japan Tobacco International and Imperial Brands. The research claims Netnografica conducted interviews with young social media influencers who were paid to promote cigarettes online to millions of followers without disclosing that they were engaged in paid advertising (those interviewed were granted anonymity to participate in the research).
Key findings from the investigation include (as alleged by the researchers and detailed in a story by The New York Times):
Tobacco companies seek out young people who have significant numbers of followers online and pay them to post photos featuring cigarette brands
Social media influencers are trained on what cigarette brands to promote, when to post pictures for maximum exposure and how to take “natural photos” that do not look like staged advertisements. In Italy, influencers paid to promote Lucky Strike cigarettes were instructed to make sure health warnings on cigarette packs were not visible in photos posted online.
Tobacco companies organize parties and contests with cigarette brand sponsorships
The companies then encourage participants to post on their social media accounts.
Influencers are instructed to include specific hashtags promoting cigarettes on social media posts
The fact that hashtags used by social media influencers are mostly in English indicates tobacco companies are targeting a global audience that includes American youth.
Combined, these deceptive social media campaigns for tobacco products have been viewed more than 25 billion times worldwide—including 8.8 billion times in the United States, according to social media analytics commissioned as part of this investigation.
The FTC regulates influencer marketing in the U.S., and the commission’s truth-in-advertising standards require influencers to clearly disclose commercial relationships to advertisers when promoting or endorsing their brands on social media. The researchers say none of the images documented in this investigation included such disclosures, despite extensive evidence that many influencers were paid or incentivized to specifically promote cigarette brands.
The petition filed calls on the FTC to issue an order requiring tobacco companies to disclose that their social media campaigns are in fact paid advertising for tobacco products by clearly including #Sponsored, #Promotion or #Ad in the content. The petition was filed by the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, American Heart Association, American Lung Association, the International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, Truth Initiative and Vital Strategies.
The social media campaigns have been documented in countries, including Brazil and Uruguay, that ban tobacco advertising on the internet. These campaigns also circumvent—and may violate—the policies of social media companies like Facebook and Instagram that do not allow paid advertising for tobacco products on their platforms.
“Tobacco companies proclaim that they don’t target kids, but this investigation shows they are doing the exact opposite—and doing so with a level of sophistication that threatens to addict a new generation and set back progress in reducing smoking around the world,” said Matthew L. Myers, president of the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, in a news release.
The investigation also shows all four major tobacco companies are violating their own internal marketing standards
These standards state that the companies will not engage in viral marketing (British American Tobacco, Imperial Brands) or covert marketing where it is not explicitly clear that cigarettes are being advertised (British American Tobacco), require age verification in online ads (Japan Tobacco International), and will engage in marketing that is “honest and accurate” (Philip Morris International).
“The evidence documented by our research represents cutting-edge, high-budget social media marketing that borrows popular themes and trends from youth culture,” said Robert Kozinets, president of Netnografica, who is also a chaired professor at the University of Southern California’s communication and business schools, in the release.
According to the investigation, the social media marketing campaigns often target low- and middle-income countries facing a disproportionately high burden of tobacco-related death and disease.
Bulldog Reporter is offering this article as a case study in how influencer marketing can be misused and the influencers themselves exploited. We are reporting that the allegations have been made, but do not claim to know their factual accuracy.
As a crowded comms landscape makes it increasingly more difficult to reach customers, smart communicators are turning to creating experiences that cut through the clutter. New research provides brands some much-needed guidance as to what drives ROI for experiential...
Staying current with the latest business trends available is not merely helpful—it’s essential to the longevity of your business. Only 12 percent of Fortune 500 companies operating in 1955 survived to the year 2016. You can be sure that the ones that thrived were...
New research from Newsweek Media Group investigates the rise of sustainable and responsible (or ESG) investing, and finds that while the Paris Climate Accord and the adoption of the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in 2015 have boosted growth in ESG investing...