Sustainability support among consumers is slipping overall in the US and Canada, lagging the global average—what it means for brands

by | Apr 25, 2024 | Public Relations

Maybe they’re fed up with the lack of progress, or just have other things to worry about, but new data from direct-to-consumer ecommerce firm ESW reveals that US consumers are less sustainably minded than they were just a year ago. Scoring just 49 this year vs. 51 in 2023, the US also lags the global mean, which is 55. What do these surprising results mean for the nation’s future ESG initiatives—and how should brands respond?

The firm’s new Global Voices report also reveals that some emerging markets are more concerned about sustainability than their counterparts in more economically mature markets. For example, India, the United Arab Emirates, China, and Mexico topped the list, with Japan , Germany, UK, Switzerland, and Canada all coming in with the lowest sustainability scores.

sustainability support

“We were surprised to discover that the degree to which consumers are concerned about sustainability, as well as what they value from the brands they patronize, depends largely upon where they live,” said Martim Avillez Oliveira, chief revenue office at ESW, in a news release. “The data suggests that while US consumers have been encouraged to make environmentally responsible choices for years, perhaps the intensity of that messaging, along with the increasing strain that inflation places on households, may have consumers at a tipping point.”

The sustainability sentiment score represents the percentage of respondents that “agree” or “strongly agree” with 14 of the sustainability sentiments, including, “I am trying to be more sustainable in my day-to-day life,” “I have stopped buying from certain brands and retailers because of their poor environmental record,” and “I try to buy/shop more sustainably, but will not spend more for more eco-friendly products.”

Other key findings include:

Sustainability by generation

In general, younger people were more concerned with sustainability than older generations.

Within the US, Millennials score highest compared to other generations, yet also declined compared to last year. Millennials scored 59 on the sustainability index, (compared to 62 last year) but still rank higher this year than Gen Z (57), Gen X (50), and Baby Boomers (35).

Global average sustainability scores by generation:

sustainability support

One-third of all global respondents are environmentally attuned shoppers

The survey classifies shoppers who scored 80 or above on the sustainability scale as environmentally attuned shoppers.

Greenwashing awareness grows

Globally, more than half of the consumers surveyed (55 percent) said they are more aware of greenwashing than they were a year ago, and 27 percent said they considered a brand’s environmental transparency record when making a purchase.

Brand name-driven consumers are more sustainably minded

Shoppers that value brand names are also more likely to be sustainably minded shoppers with a sustainability score of 62 compared to 47 for non-brand name shoppers. A third (32 percent) of brand name shoppers are likely to be environmentally attuned shoppers. Furthermore, brand name shoppers believe that a brand name means higher quality and better value. These shoppers have high expectations not just of products and services, but also of environmental records.

sustainability support

Shoppers that value brand authenticity are 50 percent more likely to be environmentally attuned shoppers

Globally, 63 percent of shoppers said that they value brand authenticity and want brands to be truthful and transparent about company environmental credentials. In addition, luxury shoppers are 1.5x more likely to be sustainably attuned shoppers.

While “sustainability” can be defined by consumers in a variety of ways, the survey found that despite this ambiguity, there are several concrete steps brands can take to attract and retain environmentally attuned shoppers. The report finds that 31 percent of consumers consider sustainable packaging options when shopping online, while 30 percent consider sustainable shipping options, and 29 percent value less packaging overall.

sustainability support

Download the full report here.

Responses were gathered from an online panel of adults 18+, representative of national quotas for key demographics in 18 countries. Survey questions and responses were translated into each country’s native language and currencies were converted to local currencies before being converted back to $US for comparison purposes. 18,679 surveys were completed between October 31st and November 14th, 2023.

Richard Carufel
Richard Carufel is editor of Bulldog Reporter and the Daily ’Dog, one of the web’s leading sources of PR and marketing communications news and opinions. He has been reporting on the PR and communications industry for over 17 years, and has interviewed hundreds of journalists and PR industry leaders. Reach him at richard.carufel@bulldogreporter.com; @BulldogReporter


11 ways outdoor brands can leverage PR for success

11 ways outdoor brands can leverage PR for success

The call of the wild resonates with many, and outdoor brands hold the coveted key to the door of adventure. Amidst a bustling marketplace brimming with tents, kayaks, and hiking boots, the challenge lies in ensuring one's brand stands out, resonating with the current...